Once a property goes under contract, the buyer’s lender orders the appraisal through a third-party system. The appraiser visits the property, evaluates condition, notes upgrades, and compares it to recent similar sales.
The final report includes photos, adjustments, and a concluded value. That value becomes the basis for the lender’s decision.
Maui is not a uniform market. Small differences in location, view, zoning, and use can create large differences in value. Short-term rental eligibility, leasehold vs fee simple ownership, proximity to the coastline, and even microclimates can materially impact pricing.
The challenge is that comparable sales are often limited or imperfect. When comps are thin or inconsistent, appraisals can become more conservative.
If the appraised value is below the contract price, the lender will base the loan on the lower value. This creates a gap that must be resolved.
- Renegotiate the purchase price
- Buyer adds additional cash
- Challenge the appraisal (rarely successful unless clearly flawed)
- Cancel the contract if contingencies allow
The best way to avoid appraisal problems is not to fight them after the fact. It is to structure the listing so that the value is supported from the beginning.
- Price based on credible, recent comparable sales
- Understand how your property differs from those comps
- Prepare a clean, well-presented property for inspection
- Provide relevant upgrades or improvements when appropriate
Overpricing with the expectation that “the market will figure it out” is one of the fastest ways to create appraisal issues.
Appraisals are not designed to disrupt transactions, but they will expose weak pricing or unsupported expectations.
The goal is not to “beat the appraisal.” The goal is to enter the transaction with a price that can withstand it.
Copyright 2025 Mateo Manzari Real Estate. All rights reserved.